Interactions of knowledge systems in shiitake mushroom production: a case study on the Noto Peninsula, Japan

Published Date

First online: 23 June 2015

Title 

Interactions of knowledge systems in shiitake mushroom production: a case study on the Noto Peninsula, Japan

• Author 

• Ryo Kohsaka 
• , Mitsuyuki Tomiyoshi
• , Osamu Saito
• , Shizuka Hashimoto
• , Leah Mohammend

• 
  

• Abstract 

• 
  

• This paper examines the relationships between traditional and modern scientific knowledge regarding shiitake mushroom production in the Ishikawa Prefecture of Japan. In the Noto Peninsula in Ishikawa Prefecture, the success of a new variety of shiitake, the Noto-Temari brand, has boosted the number of farmers, the majority of whom are new to mushroom production. Looking at the production of raw and dried mushrooms of the Noto-Temari brand, the paper compares the knowledge systems of conventional farmers and the newcomers to mushroom production. In the case of the premium-quality Noto-Temari brand, the newcomers achieve a higher rate of production than the conventional mushroom producers do. We apply the knowledge conversion framework of Polanyi (1966) to understand the dynamics of the knowledge system, and find that, in our case, traditional knowledge and techniques can be productive but can also represent obstacles to the adoption of new technology. In other words, it is possible that a knowledge of conventional technology interferes with the utilization of modern knowledge to grow the premium-quality Noto-Temari brand.

• 
  

• References 

• 
  

• 1. Bull G, Pledger S, Splittgerber M, Stephen J, Pribowo A, Baker K, Singh D, Pootlass D, Macleaod N (2014) Culturally driven forest management, utilization and values: a Nuxalk First Nations case study. For Chron 90:620–627. doi:10.​5558/​tfc2014-126 CrossRef
  2. Bürgi M, Gimmia U, Stuber M (2013) Assessing traditional knowledge on forest uses to understand forest ecosystem dynamics. For Ecol Manag 289:115–122CrossRef
  3. Byosiere P, Luethge DJ, Vas A, Paz Salmador M (2010) Diffusion of organisational innovation: knowledge transfer through social networks. Int J Technol Manag 49:401–420CrossRef
  4. Carrasco L, Nghiem T, Sunderland T, Koh L (2014) Economic valuation of ecosystem services fails to capture biodiversity value of tropical forests. Biol Conserv 178:163–170CrossRef
  5. Chun J (2014) A legal approach to induce the traditional knowledge of forest resources. For Policy Econ 38:40–45CrossRef
  6. Cottier T, Panizzon M (2004) Legal perspectives on traditional knowledge. J Int Econ Law 2:371–399CrossRef
  7. Curci J (2010) The protection of biodiversity and traditional knowledge in international law of intellectual property. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
  8. Forest Management Division, Agriculture, Forestry and Fishery Department, Ishikawa Prefecture (2012) Trends of supply and demand of minor forest products in Ishikawa Prefecture (2001–2011), Ishikawa Prefecture, Kanazawa, Japan
  9. Forestry Agency, MAFF (Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan) (2010) White paper on forest and forestry in 2010. Forestry Agency (MAFF), Tokyo
  10. Furutsuka H (2000) The marketing strategy of Japanese dried shiitake mushroom under international competition: a case study of Tottori Prefecture. J Jpn Agr Syst Soc 16(1):17–26
  11. Hansen S, Vanfleet J (2003) Traditional knowledge and intellectual property: a handbook on issues and options for traditional knowledge holders in protecting their intellectual property and maintaining biological diversity. American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), Washington, DC
  12. He J, Dong M, Stark M (2014) Small mushrooms for big business? Gaps in the sustainable management of non-timber forest products in southwest China. Sustainability 6:6847–6861
  13. Illukpitiya P, Yanagida J (2010) Farming vs forests: trade-off between agriculture and the extraction of non-timber forest products. Ecol Econ 69:1952–1963CrossRef
  14. Izatul W, Talaat W (2013) Protection of the associated traditional knowledge on genetic resources: beyond the Nagoya Protocol. Procedia 91:673–678
  15. Jensen A (2009) Valuation of non-timber forest products value chains. For Policy Econ 11:34–41CrossRef
  16. Kilchling P, Hansmann R, Seeland K (2009) Demand for non-timber forest products: surveys of urban consumers and sellers in Switzerland. For Policy Econ 11:294–300CrossRef
  17. Koohafkan P (2012) Biodiversity and traditional knowledge for climate change adaptation: lessons from globally important agricultural heritage systems (GIAHS). In: Herath S, Lim A, Wang Y, Takahashi S (eds) Proceedings of the 4th UN-CECAR Conference and Workshops Traditional Knowledge. UNU, Tokyo, pp 15–20
  18. Leistner M (2004) Traditional knowledge. In: Von Lewinski S (ed) Indigenous heritage and intellectual property. Kluwer Law, Hague, pp 52–144
  19. Matsumoto N, Furutsuka H, Matsuda T (2009) Empirical ana1ysis of the demand for dry shiitake mushrooms on the basis of their usage. J Rural Probl 45:197–202CrossRef
  20. Matsuo T (2010) Regional changes of mushroom production areas in Japan. Study Glob Environ 12:53–66
  21. Minor Forest Products Managing Office, Forestry Management Improvement Division, Forestry Agency, MAFF (2012) Basic information on minor forest products 2011. http://​www.​e-stat.​go.​jp/​SG1/​estat/​List.​do?​lid=​000001105433. Accessed 30 July 2013
  22. Nonaka I, Takeuchi H (1995) The knowledge-creating company: How Japanese companies create the dynamics of innovation. Oxford University Press, New York, p 284
  23. Oku-Noto Shitake Promotion Group, Ishikawa Prefecture, Ishikawa Branch of the National Federation of Agricultural Cooperative Associations (2013) Activity report, October 2010–February 2013, Ishikawa, Kanazawa, Japan
  24. Polanyi M (1966) The tacit dimension. Routledge, London
  25. Rista L, Shanley P, Sunderland T, Sheil D, Ndoyee O, Liswantic N, Tieguhong J (2012) The impacts of selective logging on non-timber forest products of livelihood importance. For Ecol Manage 268:57–69CrossRef
  26. Secretariat on Convention of Biological Diversity (SCBD) (2011) REDD-plus and biodiversity. CBD Technical Series no. 59. SCBD, Montreal
  27. Van Overwalle G (2005) Protecting and sharing biodiversity and traditional knowledge: holder and user tools. Ecol Econ 53:585–607. doi:10.​1016/​j.​ecolecon.​2004.​10.​014 CrossRef
  28. Von Lewinski S (2008) Introduction. In: Von Lewinski S (ed) Indigenous heritage and intellectual property. Kluwer Law, Hague, pp 1–5
  29. WIPO (2001) Intellectual property needs and expectations of traditional knowledge holders (WIPO Report on Fact-finding Missions on Intellectual Property and Traditional Knowledge). WIPO, Geneva
  30. Yashima T (2012) Relationship between log size and mushroom size at log cultivation of Lentinula edodes. Ishikawa-ken For Exp Stn Res Bull Ishikawa-ken Shinrin Shikenjo 44:33–35
  31. Yashima T, Kodani J, Yagami T (2014) Relationship of production and temperature for Noto-Temari. Ishikawa-ken For Exp Stn Res Bull Ishikawa-ken Shinrin Shikenjo 46:14–15
  32. Zeidemann V, Kainer A, Staudhammer C (2013) Heterogeneity in NTFP quality, access and management shape benefit distribution in an Amazonian extractive reserve. Environ Conserv 41:242–252CrossRef

• 
  

• For further details log on website :

• http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10310-015-0491-4