Substrate comparison for short-term success of a multispecies tree plantation in thickened tailings of a boreal gold mine

Author

• Marie Guittonny-Larchevêque 
• , Carl Pednault

Abstract

Tree planting can accelerate the conversion of mine sites into forests after closure, thereby decreasing environmental impacts on forested landscapes. However, few studies have investigated tree planting to reclaim metalliferous mine tailings. To mitigate the restrictions to tree growth associated with mine tailings, soils and amendments can be used. A 2-year field experiment was conducted in low-sulphur thickened tailings of a gold mine under boreal conditions. We aimed to select the best substrate to establish multispecies plantations. We compared the effects of (1) increasing the topsoil volume and thickness, (2) amending tailings and overburden with greenwaste compost, and (3) direct planting in the tailings on the establishment of Larix laricina (Du Roi) K. Koch, Pinus banksiana Lamb., Salix viminalis L., and P. × canadensis Moench × P. maximowiczii A. Henry. Trees did not survive the first winter when planted directly in tailings, but compost addition to tailings increased survival through substrate structure improvement. However, survival and growth remained lower for three species planted in the compost and tailings mixture compared to soil treatments. Tree roots did not colonize tailings underlying the compost and tailings mixture, whereas roots were present in tailings underlying soil layers. In overburden amended with compost, survival and growth rates were similar to those for trees planted in topsoil of the same thickness. Adding compost to tailings or mineral soil improved the P nutrition of trees, which appeared a limiting nutrient in this study. Tree growth was influenced by topsoil thickness (50 vs. 20 cm) rather than volume (20 cm layer vs. 20 cm deep planting holes); trees grown in the thicker topsoil showed the highest N nutrition and aerial growth.

References

1. Abrahão A, Lambers H, Sawaya ACHF, Mazzafera P, Oliveira RS (2014) Convergence of a specialized root trait in plants from nutrient-impoverished soils: phosphorus-acquisition strategy in a nonmycorrhizal cactus. Oecologia 176:345–355CrossRefPubMed
2. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (2012) The Canadian system of soil classification, 3rd edn. http://​sis.​agr.​gc.​ca/​cansis/​taxa/​cssc3/​intro.​html. Accessed 5 July 2012
3. Al TA, Blowes DW (1999) The hydrogeology of a tailings impoundment formed by central discharge of thickened tailings: implications for tailings management. J Cont Hydrol 38:489–505CrossRef
4. Angers DA, Caron J (1998) Plant-induced changes in soil structure: processes and feedbacks. Biogeochemistry 42(1/2):55–72CrossRef
5. Archer JR, Smith PD (1972) The relation between bulk density, available water capacity, and air capacity of soils. J Soil Sci 23(4):475–480CrossRef
6. Aubertin M, Bussière B, Bernier L (2002) Environnement et gestion des résidus miniers. Cédérom. Les Éditions de l’École Polytechnique de Montréal
7. Barbour SL, Wilson GW, St-Arnaud LC (1993) Evaluation of the saturated-unsaturated groundwater conditions of a thickened tailings deposit. Can Geotech J 30:935–946CrossRef
8. Bendfeldt ES, Burger JA, Daniels WL (2001) Quality of amended mine soils after sixteen years. Soil Sci Soc Am J 65:1736–1744CrossRef
9. Bending NAD, Moffat AJ (1999) Tree performance on minespoils in the South Wales coalfield. J Appl Ecol 36:784–797CrossRef
10. Bjugstad AJ (1986) Hybrid poplar cultivars for maximizing phytomass production on gold mine tailings in the Black Hills. In: National symposium on mining, hydrology, sedimentology, and reclamation, 8–11 Dec, University of Kentucky, Lexington
11. Bouyoucos GJ (1962) Hydrometer method improved for making particle-size analysis of soils. Agronomy J 54:464–465CrossRef
12. Boyter MJ, Brummer JE, Leininger WC (2009) Growth and metal accumulation of Geyer and mountain willow grown in topsoil versus amended mine tailings. Water Air Soil Pollut 198:17–29CrossRef
13. Burger JA, Zipper CE (2002) How to restore forests on surface-mined land. Reclamation guidelines for surface mined land in Southwest Virginia. Virginia Cooperative Extension, Powell River Series Publication, pp 460–123
14. Bussière B (2007) Colloquium 2004: hydrogeotechnical properties of hard rock tailings from metal mines and emerging geoenvironmental disposal approaches. Can Geotech J 44:1019–1052CrossRef
15. Cassel DK, Nielsen DR (1986) Field capacity and available water capacity. In: Methods of soil analysis. Part 1—physical and mineralogical methods. Agronomy Series No 9, ASA Inc., SSSA Inc., Madison, WO, USA, pp 901–926
16. Cooke JA, Johnson MS (2002) Ecological restoration of land with particular reference to the mining of metals and industrial minerals: a review of theory and practice. Environ Rev 10:41–71CrossRef
17. De Nicola F, Maisto G, Alfani A (2003) Assessment of nutritional status and trace element contamination of holm oak woodlands through analyses of leaves and surrounding soils. Sci Total Environ 311:191–203CrossRefPubMed
18. Dere AL, Stehouwer RC, McDonald KE (2008) Nutrient fluxes from abandoned mine soils reclaimed with poultry manure and paper mill sludge. In: Barnhisel RI (ed) National Meeting of the American Society of Mining and Reclamation, Richmond, VA, New Opportunities to Apply Our Science, 14–19 June 2008. ASMR, Lexington, KY, pp 298–315
19. Emerson P, Skousen J, Ziemkiewicz P (2009) Survival and growth of hardwoods in brown versus gray sandstone on a surface mine in West Virginia. J Environ Qual 38:1821–1829CrossRefPubMed
20. Environment Canada (2004) National climate archives. http://​climate.​weatheroffice.​ec.​gc.​ca/​index.​html. Accessed 26 Apr 2012
21. Evanylo GK, Abaye AO, Dundas C, Zipper CE, Lemus R, Sukkariyah B, Rockett J (2005) Herbaceous vegetation productivity, persistence, and metals uptake on a biosolids-amended mine soil. J Environ Qual 34:1811–1819CrossRefPubMed
22. Hansen EA, McLaughlin RA, Pope PE (1988) Biomass and nitrogen dynamics of hybrid poplar on two different soils: implications for fertilization strategy. Can J For Res 18:223–230CrossRef
23. Holl KD (2002) Long-term vegetation recovery on reclaimed coal surface mines in the eastern USA. J Appl Ecol 39:960–970CrossRef
24. Kabata-Pendias A, Pendias H (2001) Trace elements in soil and plants, 3rd edn. CRC Press, Boca Raton
25. Klute A (1986) Water retention: Laboratory methods. In: Methods of soil analysis. Part 1—physical and mineralogical methods. Agronomy Series No 9, ASA Inc., SSSA Inc., Madison, WO, USA, pp 635–662
26. Kost DA, Vimmerstedt JP, Brown JH (1998) Site factor effects on establishment of planted and volunteer trees and shrubs on graded cast overburden and replaced topsoil in southeastern Ohio. Int J Surf Min Reclam Environ 12(2):79–86CrossRef
27. Labrecque M, Teodorescu TI (2001) Influence of plantation site and wastewater sludge fertilization on the performance and foliar nutrient status of two willow species grown under SRIC in southern Quebec (Canada). For Ecol Manage 150:223–239CrossRef
28. Larchevêque M, DesRochers A, LaRocque GR (2011) Comparison of manure compost and mineral fertilizer for hybrid poplar plantation establishment on boreal heavy clay soils. Ann For Sci 68(4):849–860CrossRef
29. Larchevêque M, Desrochers A, Bussière B, Cartier H, Baribeault C, Pednault C, David J-S (2012) How to grow trees on the wastes of a boreal gold mine—identification of the main physic-chemical limitations. In: Fourie AB, Tibbett M (eds) Proceedings of mine closure 2012, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp 467–480
30. Larchevêque M, Desrochers A, Bussière B, Cartier H, David J-S (2013) Revegetation of non-acid-generating, thickened tailings with boreal trees: a greenhouse study. J Environ Qual 42:351–360CrossRefPubMed
31. Lieffers VJ, Macdonald SE (1990) Growth and foliar nutrient status of black spruce and tamarack in relation to depth of water table in some Alberta peatlands. Can J For Res 20:805–809CrossRef
32. Macdonald E, Landhäusser SM, Skousen J, Franklin J, Frouz J, Hall S, Jacobs DF, Quideau S (2015) Forest restoration following surface mining disturbance: challenges and solutions. New For 46:703–732CrossRef
33. Maiti SK (2007) Bioreclamation of coalmine overburden dumps—with special emphasis on micronutrients and heavy metals accumulation in tree species. Environ Monit Assess 125:111–122CrossRefPubMed
34. Markert B, Kayser G, Korhammer S, Oehlmann J (2000) Distribution and effects of trace substances in soils, plants and animals. In: Vernet JP (ed) Trace elements: Their distribution and effects in the environment, 4th edn. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 3–32CrossRef
35. McMillan R, Quideau SA, MacKenzie MD, Biryukova O (2007) Nitrogen mineralization and microbial activity in oil sands reclaimed boreal forest soils. J Environ Qual 36:1470–1478CrossRefPubMed
36. Meredith HL, Patrick WH (1961) Effects of soil compaction on subsoil root penetration and physical properties of three soils in Louisiana. Agronomy J 53:163–167CrossRef
37. Michels A, Barton C, Cushing T, Angel P, Sweigard R, Graves D (2007) Evaluation of low spoil compaction techniques for hardwood forest establishment on an eastern Kentucky surface mine. In: Barnhisel RI (ed) National Meeting of the American Society of Mining and Reclamation, 2–7 June, Gillette, WY. ASMR, Lexington, KY, pp 492–503
38. Mosseler A, Major JE, Labrecque M (2014) Growth and survival of seven native willow species on highly disturbed coal mine sites in eastern Canada. Can J For Res 44:340–349CrossRef
39. Olsen SR, Cole CV, Watanave FS, Dean LA (1954) Pages 1–19 in: Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate, Circ. USDA, 939
40. Parrotta JA, Turnbull JW, Jones N (1997) Catalyzing native forest regeneration on degraded tropical lands. For Ecol Manage 99:1–7CrossRef
41. Quebec Government (2014) Annexe I—Règlement sur la protection et la réhabilitation des terrains, Loi sur la qualité de l’environnement, Chapitre Q2 r.37. http://​www2.​publicationsduqu​ebec.​gouv.​qc.​ca/​dynamicSearch/​telecharge.​php?​type=​3&​file=​/​Q_​2/​Q2R37.​htm. Accessed 2 Dec 2015
42. Ramsay WJH (1986) Bulk soil handling for quarry restoration. Soil Use Manag 2:30–39CrossRef
43. Renault S, Markham J, Davis L, Martin M (2008) Revegetation of gold mine tailings in Nopiming provincial park, Manitoba. In: Barnhisel RI (ed) New opportunities to apply our science, National Meeting of the American Society of Mining and Reclamation, 14–19 June, Richmond, VA. ASMR, Lexington, KY, p 910
44. Robinsky E, Barbour SL, Wilson GW, Bordin D, Fredlund DG (1991) Thickened sloped tailings disposal—an evaluation of seepage and abatement of acid drainage. In: Proceedings of the 2nd international conference on the abatement of acidic drainage, 16–18 Sept, Montréal, QC, pp 529–549
45. Rosselli W, Keller C, Boschi K (2003) Phytoextraction capacity of trees growing on a metal contaminated soil. Plant Soil 256:265–272CrossRef
46. Stehouwer R, Day RL, Macneal KE (2006) Nutrient and trace element leaching following mine reclamation with biosolids. J Environ Qual 35:1118–1126CrossRefPubMed
47. Strong WL (2000) Vegetation development on reclaimed lands in the Coal Valley Mine of western Alberta, Canada. Can J Bot 78:110–118
48. Tordoff GM, Baker AJM, Willis AJ (2000) Current approaches to the revegetation and reclamation of metalliferous mine wastes. Chemosphere 41:219–228CrossRefPubMed
49. van den Driessche R (1999) First-year growth response of four Populus trichocarpa × Populus deltoïdes clones to fertilizer placement and level. Can J For Res 29:554–562
50. Vervaeke P, Luyssaert S, Mertens J, Meers E, Tack FMG, Lust N (2003) Phytoremediation prospects of willow stands on contaminated sediment: a field trial. Environ Pollut 126:275–282CrossRefPubMed
51. Winterhalder K (1995) Dynamics of plant communities and soils in revegetated ecosystems: a Sudbury case study. In: Gunn JM (ed) Restoration and recovery of an industrial region. Springer, New-York, pp 173–182CrossRef
52. Zhang ZQ, Shu WS, Lan CY, Wong MH (2001) Soil seed bank as an input of seed source in revegetation of lead/zinc mine tailings. Restor Ecol 9(4):378–385CrossRef

For further details log on website :
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11056-016-9543-7