Dissolving the ‘problem of the absent artifact’: Design representations as means for counterfactual understanding and knowledge generalisation

Published Date
Design Studies
July 2015, Vol.39:1–18, doi:10.1016/j.destud.2015.04.001

Author 

• Dingmar van Eck ^,

• Ghent University, Centre for Logic and Philosophy of Science, Blandijnberg 2, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium

Available online 28 April 2015. 

Highlights

• The ‘problem of the absent artifact’ is a pseudo-problem.
• •
  Norms pertaining to ‘truth’ conditions do not apply to the assessment of propositions based on design representations.
• •
  Design representations are means for counterfactual understanding and knowledge generalization.

It has been argued by Per Galle that a viable account of designing should address the ‘problem of the absent artifact’. The problem concerns the nature of design representations. Specifically, the question how one can utter true statements, in terms of design representations, about artifacts when these artifacts are, in the design phase, still non-existent. This paper exposes the problem as a pseudo-problem. It is argued that design representations are not means for the production of truth-apt assertions. This dissolves the ‘absent artifact problem’. An alternative view is elaborated according to which design representations are means for counterfactual understanding, knowledge generalisation, and knowledge unification. Examples from the functional modelling literature are used to illustrate these roles.

Keywords

epistemology

philosophy of design

conceptual design

design representation

---

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

• ∗ 
  Corresponding author: Dingmar van Eck.
  
  

For further details log on website :
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0142694X15000265